Research On The Leading Edge
The Hall Center will provide free copies of Machery’s book, Philosophy Within Its Proper Bounds, in advance, to be read prior to the event by KU faculty and graduate students who wish to participate. Please RSVP to this event by March 15 at firstname.lastname@example.org to confirm that you wish to attend and would like a copy of the book.
In Philosophy Within Its Proper Bounds, Edouard Machery argues that resolving many traditional and contemporary philosophical issues is beyond our epistemic reach and that philosophy should re-orient itself toward more humble, but ultimately more important intellectual endeavors. The book assesses the main philosophical method for acquiring the knowledge that the resolution of these traditional and contemporary philosophical issues turns on: the use of thought experiments in philosophy. Canvassing the extensive work done by experimental philosophers over the last 15 years, Edouard Machery shows that thought experiments are an extremely unreliable method for gaining knowledge. Importantly, the dismissal of the incriminated traditional and contemporary philosophical issues is no cause for despair - many important philosophical issues remain within our epistemic reach. In particular, reorienting the course of philosophy would free time and resources for bringing back to prominence a once-central intellectual endeavor: conceptual analysis and engineering.
In addition to philosophers, Philosophy Within Its Proper Bounds should be of interest to behavioral scientists because of the importance of behavioral methods in experimental philosophy. Anthropologists and specialists of non-Western societies (comparative philosophers, global historians, etc.) will be interested by the importance of cultural diversity in this criticism of the methods dominant of contemporary Western philosophy. The defense of conceptual analysis and conceptual engineering will resonate both with scientists (including those working in the so-called hard sciences) and with humanists interested in the creation of new forms of thoughts.
This workshop is part of the Hall Center’s Research on the Leading Edge program, which brings visiting scholars to campus who have published, or who are working upon, research that is boundary shifting within the humanities and humanistic social sciences.
No formal presentation will be given by the guest scholar. A panel of KU faculty members will critique the book prior to the author’s response, followed by a general discussion. This session’s panelists are: John Symons (Philosophy), Anna Neill (English), and Chris Crandall (Psychology).
Past Sessions of Research On the Leading Edge
Fall 2018 – Ruben Espinosa, English, UTEP: “Shakespeare in the Shadows”
Dr. Espinosa is an Associate Professor of English at the University of Texas at El Paso, where he specializes in Shakespeare and early modern studies. He is currently working on a book-length project that employs critical race and ethnic studies to examine how the issues of race, language, ethnic identity, assimilation, and immigration not only inform our understanding of Shakespeare’s contemporary, cultural value in our diversified world, but also allow us to scrutinize the meaningful intersections of Shakespeare and Latinx identity and culture.
Spring 2018 – LaShawn D. Harris, History, Michigan State University: “Sex Workers, Psychics, and Numbers Runners: Black Women in New York City’s Underground Economy”
During the early twentieth century, a diverse group of African American women carved out unique niches for themselves within New York City's expansive informal economy. LaShawn Harris illuminates the labor patterns and economic activity of three perennials within this kaleidoscope of underground industry: sex work, numbers running for gambling enterprises, and the supernatural consulting business. Mining police and prison records, newspaper accounts, and period literature, Harris teases out answers to essential questions about these women and their working lives. She also offers a surprising revelation. Harris argues that the underground economy catalyzed working-class black women's creation of the employment opportunities, occupational identities, and survival strategies that provided them with financial stability and a sense of labor autonomy and mobility. At the same time, Harris shows, urban black women strove for economic and social prospects and pleasures, and in the process experienced the conspicuous and hidden dangers associated with newfound labor opportunities.
Fall 2017 – Or Rosenboim, Modern History, City University of London: “The Emergence of Globalism: Visions of World Order in Britain and the United States, 1939-1950”
Shedding critical light on this neglected chapter in the history of political thought, Or Rosenboim describes how a transnational network of globalist thinkers emerged from the traumas of war and expatriation in the 1940s and how their ideas drew widely from political philosophy, geopolitics, economics, imperial thought, constitutional law, theology, and philosophy of science. She presents compelling portraits of Raymond Aron, Owen Lattimore, Lionel Robbins, Barbara Wootton, Friedrich Hayek, Lionel Curtis, Richard McKeon, Michael Polanyi, Lewis Mumford, Jacques Maritain, Reinhold Niebuhr, H. G. Wells, and others. Rosenboim shows how the globalist debate they embarked on sought to balance the tensions between a growing recognition of pluralism on the one hand and an appreciation of the unity of humankind on the other.
Spring 2017 – Tara Zahra, East European History, University of Chicago: “The Great Departure: Mass Migration from Eastern Europe and the Making of the Free World”
Between 1846 and 1940, more than 50 million Europeans moved to the Americas in one of the largest migrations of human history, emptying out villages and irrevocably changing both their new homes and the ones they left behind. With a keen historical perspective on the most consequential social phenomenon of the twentieth century, Tara Zahra shows how the policies that gave shape to this migration provided the precedent for future events such as the Holocaust, the closing of the Iron Curtain, and the tragedies of ethnic cleansing. In the epilogue, she places the current refugee crisis within the longer history of migration.
Fall 2016 – Michael Duneier, Sociology, Princeton University: “Ghetto: The Invention of a Place, the History of an Idea”
In this sweeping and original account, Mitchell Duneier traces the idea of the ghetto from its beginnings in the sixteenth century and its revival by the Nazis to the present. As Duneier shows, we cannot comprehend the entanglements of race, poverty, and place in America today without recalling the ghettos of Europe, as well as earlier efforts to understand the problems of the American city.
Fall 2015 – Karla Holloway, English, Duke University: “Legal Fictions: Constituting Race, Composing Literature”
In Legal Fictions, Karla FC Holloway both argues that U.S. racial identity is the creation of U.S. law and demonstrates how black authors of literary fiction have engaged with the law's constructions of race since the era of slavery. Exploring the resonance between U.S. literature and U.S. jurisprudence, Holloway reveals Toni Morrison's Beloved and Charles Johnson's Middle Passage as stories about personhood and property, David Bradley's The Chaneysville Incident and Ralph Ellison's Invisible Manas structured by evidence law, and Nella Larsen's Passing as intimately related to contract law. Holloway engages the intentional, contradictory, and capricious constructions of race embedded in the law with the same energy that she brings to her masterful interpretations of fiction by U.S. writers. Her readings shed new light on the many ways that black U.S. authors have reframed fundamental questions about racial identity, personhood, and the law from the nineteenth into the twenty-first centuries. Legal Fictions is a bold declaration that the black body is thoroughly bound by law and an unflinching look at the implications of that claim.
Spring 2015 – Edward Baptist, History, Cornell: “The Half That Has Never Been Told: Slavery and the Making of American Capitalism”
As historian Edward Baptist reveals in The Half Has Never Been Told, the expansion of slavery in the first eight decades after American independence drove the evolution and modernization of the United States. In the span of a single lifetime, the South grew from a narrow coastal strip of worn-out tobacco plantations to a continental cotton empire, and the United States grew into a modern, industrial, and capitalist economy. Until the Civil War, Baptist explains, the most important American economic innovations were ways to make slavery ever more profitable. Through forced migration and torture, slave owners extracted continual increases in efficiency from enslaved African Americans. Thus, the United States seized control of the world market for cotton, the key raw material of the Industrial Revolution, and became a wealthy nation with global influence.
Fall 2014 – Julian Go, Sociology, Boston University: “Patterns of Empire”
Patterns of Empire comprehensively examines the two most powerful empires in modern history: the United States and Britain. Challenging the popular theory that the American empire is unique, Patterns of Empire shows how the policies, practices, forms and historical dynamics of the American empire repeat those of the British, leading up to the present climate of economic decline, treacherous intervention in the Middle East and overextended imperial confidence. A critical exercise in revisionist history and comparative social science, this book also offers a challenging theory of empire that recognizes the agency of non-Western peoples, the impact of global fields and the limits of imperial power.